Gen-Z With Gray Hair
Born in 1997, and showing a concerning amount of gray hair, some of my earliest memories involve gaming on my family's Windows XP computer, watching VHS tapes on a big CRT screen, and exploring websites built with Adobe Flash. I think I can call myself fortunate to have grown up in such a time of technological revolution such as has been seen over the nearly 30 years I have been alive, but I also recognize the harms that came about to my generation from having unfettered access to the Internet, no screen time limits, and chronic reliance on predatory tech companies, who continue to exploit us and our children.
On the whole, society was, and still is, seeking to understand how to best respond to technologies that are rapidly evolving, even faster now with the advent of Large Language Models. I think I want this blog to provide a different voice in this conversation for parents that hold concerns about technology, but are uncertain of what to do about it as far as parenting goes. I'm not some parenting expert who pretends to know what is best for every child; I'm just a father who is trying to figure out how to best handle technology in the household.
For my own children, an infant and a toddler, I seek to not repeat the mistakes I see in the relationship between parents, children, and technology: (1) holding an outright prohibition on forms of technology, (2) adopting a laissez-faire approach, (3) or obsessively controlling every facet of a child's digital life until adulthood. Each of these extremes, in my personal experiences of childhood and working with youth, are dysfunctional approaches to digital parenting. I offer the following explanations of each extreme:
(1): Prohibition
In seeking to protect their children, some parents prohibit hardware like smartphones or software like social media in order to shield their children from the terrible things and terrible people that are online. I think this drive is noble and important, but, like the actual Prohibition era, it drives children to secrecy and they usually figure out how to access prohibited software behind the parent's back anyway.
(2): Laissez-faire
In seeking to provide their children the greatest levels of freedom and self-autonomy, some parents permit the unmoderated use of technology. This was closest to what I had growing up and allowed me to access web content of which I should never have been exposed to and to converse with anyone on the Internet.
(3): Authoritarianism
I do not have a charitable way of speaking about this kind of digital authoritarianism. Some parents exert control over their children's devices because they are fulfilling some need for control over something in their life. Oftentimes, this form of digital control is symptomatic of broader issues in the parent-child relationship.
Somewhere, there is a balance to be struck between the protection of children from inappropriate content/Internet strangers, protection from exploitation by advertising/social media companies, and the social/developmental needs of children growing up in the digital era. At present time, with my toddler becoming more interested in computers and gaming, I see a need for firm guardrails and screen-time limits. I expect this to change and develop as my children grow into adults capable of holding an ethical and moderated relationship with technology and the broader world around them. I think that an answer to this conundrum lies within careful attentiveness by parents, rejection of the exploitation of users by tech companies, and the embrace of Free and Open Source Software (FOSS).